(no subject)
Oct. 11th, 2012 11:25 amAnd now an extraneous, minor, overlong, petty rant about more obscure game stuff.
I don't actually like Dragonlance. Thanks to TSR's attitude of this-is-a-modern-classic-equivalent-to-Tolkien while I was growing up, it took me years to realize that that weird feeling in my head wasn't minor crankiness but full-on dislike. Hate's a bit strong for a fictional series. Thanks to TSR's attitude while I was growing up, I have no idea whether I am a weirdo or preaching to the choir.
I admit to being suckered in by Larry Elmore's art - it is pretty awesome - and especially by that beautiful, beautiful, beautiful map of Xak Tsaroth. That map was more seductive than the map for freakin' Ravenloft, that's how gorgeous it was. But here's what I don't like;
It took me the longest time to realize this minor, stupid, pointless thing. Thank you.
I don't actually like Dragonlance. Thanks to TSR's attitude of this-is-a-modern-classic-equivalent-to-Tolkien while I was growing up, it took me years to realize that that weird feeling in my head wasn't minor crankiness but full-on dislike. Hate's a bit strong for a fictional series. Thanks to TSR's attitude while I was growing up, I have no idea whether I am a weirdo or preaching to the choir.
I admit to being suckered in by Larry Elmore's art - it is pretty awesome - and especially by that beautiful, beautiful, beautiful map of Xak Tsaroth. That map was more seductive than the map for freakin' Ravenloft, that's how gorgeous it was. But here's what I don't like;
- The plot twist. Morgoth and Sauron want to take over Middle Earth and once they get the place it's gonna be permanent. Much as I like hot women who also are multiheaded multicolored evil dragon-goddesses, it was sort of a disappointment to find out that all she's really after are gemstones stuck in some dude's torso, and that whole send unstoppable evil armies to bring darkness and fear across the world is only a feint.
- The comic relief. Whole races are comic relief. The kender are comic relief, the gully dwarves are comic relief, the gnomes are comic relief, Fizbin the Magnificent is comic relief, knights with gigantic droopy mustaches are comic relief, the dwarf's fake allergy to horses is comic relief, whasserface hitting bad guys with a pan is comic relief. So much of the series tries so hard to be funny that it flops.
- In related news, racism. Whole races are like the single type specimen you run into. Nowhere do you ever run into a kender who loved adventurous tales of the good Solomnaic Knights and who decided that she, too, was going to stomp around in armor fighting evil. Nowhere do you ever run into a gnome who, frustrated by the continuous malfunction of steam tech, turned to the dark faith of Takhisis. When the minotaurs are the most individually diverse non-humans out there, your AD&D campaign's got some problems...
- A weird lack of hope. I know this is going to sound weird for a good-guys-triumph series but... you have the gnomes. They make bizarre tech which doesn't work, and yet they never turn around and save the day with it. You have the kender, and their tendency to pick stuff up and be curious doesn't turn around and save the day. You have Sturm who dies bravely and it's a waste, his honor doesn't save the day; you have Flint Fireforge, and when he goes because people get old, there's no real tradeoff that Flint's age helped him save the world or whatever. You have Tanis who theoretically should be the hero in danger of falling to darkness and being redeemed, and yet he isn't very interesting. And you have Raistlin, who theoretically should be the hero in danger of falling to darkness and being redeemed, and guess what? He's eeeeevil evil evil. It does not help here that all of these kinda tank-brained wholesome folk get to be the good guys, and the smart guy's evil. The whole thing is sort of wabi-sabi through the wholesome midwestern filter.
- The ongoing adventures. Gah. I can't even track everything going on in middle-earth or Lankhmar, let alone the glut of Dragonlance everything that TSR spewed forth unto the world. It's a little like Star Wars that way, except Star Wars was mostly cool. At some point the source of things should give way to the imaginations of the fans, maybe - especially with stuff that came out of a roleplaying game.
It took me the longest time to realize this minor, stupid, pointless thing. Thank you.